Reviewing Nostalgia Countertop Toaster Ovens


Our review process

Are you on the hunt for a new toaster oven but don't know where to start looking? We have gathered, reviewed, and analyzed information for various types of toaster ovens in order to show you our top ranked toaster ovens today. Check out the benefits and disadvantages of some of the main specs for Nostalgia countertop toaster ovens.

Before you choose your new Nostalgia countertop toaster oven, here are some things you may want to consider. Nostalgia was founded in 2008. Nostalgia manufactures various products, which include specialty appliances, tea and coffee machines, and more. It creates designs that are inspired by early 19th century America. Countertop toaster ovens are ready to use, so you can bake food whenever you want. However, they can take up more counter space, so you might not have enough room for your other kitchen appliances.

Our Top Ranking Toaster Ovens
Best Overall Score
An image of Nostalgia Retro SS1511TW-4700 Retro Red Convection Countertop Large 12 Slice Toaster Oven

Take your cooking experience to the next level with the Nostalgia Retro Red Countertop Convection 12-Slice Toaster Oven. This stainless steel toaster oven is a versatile choice that will blend in with all your existing kitchen appliances. Made with a baking function, this toaster oven allows you to make anything from scones to pies. It uses convection heating to toast your food more quickly and evenly. With a red shade, it is the perfect choice for adding a hint of color to your kitchen. This large toaster oven is ideal for big families since you can cook a lot of food at one time.

Designed with a retro look, this toaster oven will blend together with any contemporary kitchen decor and appliances that you may have. It has adjustable temperature, which prevents your food from burning or over cooking. It has a clear-view glass door, so you can easily see what's going on inside the oven. This toaster oven includes a baking pan and two nickel-plated racks.

    Pros
    • Stainless steel build won't discolor or fade over time
    • Large build is great for big families
    • Baking function gives you a challenging hobby to start
    Cons
    • Convection heating means breads and cakes are less likely to raise
    • Retro red shade can be difficult to match with other appliances
    • Stainless steel build requires more cleaning
Runner Up
An image of Nostalgia Retro RTOV220AQ Aqua Convection Countertop Large 12 Slice Toaster Oven

Toast all your favorite meals to perfection by using the Nostalgia Retro Aqua Countertop Convection 12-Slice Toaster Oven. This toaster oven has adjustable temperature, which prevents your food from over cooking or burning. It has a baking function, is constructed for toasting, and is built for broiling, requiring less oil than other ways of cooking. With a retro look, it will blend together with any modern appliances and kitchen decor that you may have. This toaster oven has nickel-plated racks, which have excellent corrosion and wear resistance. Designed with a large build, it is ideal for big families since you can make a lot of food at one time. It is aqua to add a little bit of color to your countertops without being too overwhelming.

Using convection heating technology, this toaster oven cooks your food more evenly and quickly. Constructed with a removable crumb tray, it will keep your counters tidy and free of crumbs. The timer can be set for up to 60 minutes, so you don't have to keep track of how long your food has been toasting for. This toaster oven is ideal for warming up bread and pizza.

    Pros
    • Adjustable temperature prevents your food from over cooking or burning
    • Large size is great for big households
    • Nickel-plated racks have excellent wear and corrosion resistance
    Cons
    • Convection heating means cakes and breads are not as likely to raise
    • Aqua hue can be too overwhelming in your cooking area
Additional Picks
An image of Nostalgia Retro BSET300AQ Aqua Countertop Family Size Four Slice Toaster Oven

Choose the Nostalgia Retro Aqua Countertop 4-Slice Toaster Oven to cook and warm your food to perfection. Featuring a removable crumb tray, this toaster oven will keep your counters tidy and crumb-free. It has a toasting function, is built for coffee making, and is constructed with toasting, coffee making, and baking functions, so you can perfect new recipes from cookies to pies. This toaster oven is suitable for heating up eggs and bread. It has an easy-to-clean construction, which will allow you to simply wipe away any residue with a damp towel or cloth.

This family size toaster oven can accommodate big items. With an aqua design, this toaster oven will brighten any kitchen without being too overwhelming. It features two knobs and three pre-set functions for you to choose from. This toaster oven is designed with auto shutoff and has a heat-resistant handle, which keeps your hands free from burns.

    Pros
    • Designed with a family size build, making it ideal for large households
    • Heat-resistant handle keeps your hands free from getting injured
    • Baking function allows you to make anything from cakes to pies
    Cons
    • Aqua shade might go out of fashion
    • Four-slice capacity may takes more time to toast your bread
Still Need Help Narrowing Down Your Options? Here's Some Additional Information to Consider:
Capacity for a Nostalgia Countertop Toaster Oven
3-4 Slice Toaster Ovens

If you're looking for a toaster oven that can handle your family's toasting demands, then a 3-4 slice toaster oven may be the best solution. We found three 3-4 slice Nostalgia countertop toaster ovens on the market. Click here to check one out. Generally equipped with more browning controls, 3-4 slice toaster ovens give you total control over your food's crispiness. With increased toasting capacity, they will let you make toast for anyone that wants. They have uneven toasting, resulting in hot and cold spots in the food. 3-4 slice toaster ovens aren't suitable for large households, so if you're looking for a toaster oven for your family to use, you might want to consider one with a larger capacity. They are a bit bulky in size, so if you have small kitchen or limited room on your counter top, you should consider getting a smaller toaster oven.

Over 9 Slice Toaster Ovens

If you're looking for a toaster oven that can make enough toast for your entire family in just one round, then an over 9 slice toaster oven may be just what you need. For your convenience, we found three over 9 slice Nostalgia countertop toaster ovens that are available today. With increased cooking capacity, over 9 slice toaster ovens save you valuable time when your family is in a rush to get out the door. Typically designed with multiple browning controls, they give you total control over how crispy you want your food. They are perfect for families, so more than one person can toast their food simultaneously. Over 9 slice toaster ovens tend to produce uneven toasting, so there might be some hot and cold spots in the food after toasting. They are usually expensive, so if you're shopping on a budget, you might want to look for another kind of toaster oven. They are a bit bulky in size, so if you have small kitchen or limited space on your counter top, you should consider getting a smaller toaster oven.