Best Aluminum Toaster Ovens


Our review process

Are you on the hunt for a new toaster oven but don't know where to begin your search? We have collected, researched, and analyzed information for various types of toaster ovens in order to show you our top scoring toaster ovens on the market. Check out some of the pros and cons of some of the main specs for aluminum toaster ovens.

If you are searching for an appliance that effectively cooks all your favorite foods, aluminum toaster ovens will get the job done. Built of materials that are easy to clean, aluminum toaster ovens can be simply wiped down with a wet cloth or towel to get rid of any residue. They feature excellent rust resistance, tolerating many years of use without showing any signs of its age. However, they have heat transmitting materials, allowing your food to get colder quickly. Additionally, they are more likely to scratch, making them less durable compared to other materials.

Our Top Ranking Toaster Ovens
Best Overall Score
An image of Elite Cuisine ERO-2008SZ Black Convection Countertop Extra Large Toaster Oven

Make delicious, toasted meals by using the Elite Cuisine Black Countertop Convection Toaster Oven. This toaster oven is constructed for broiling, features a rotisserie cooking function, and is built for baking, so you can perfect new recipes from cookies to cakes. Featuring an aluminum construction, it is a lightweight yet durable choice. It is black, giving your kitchen an industrial appearance. This extra large toaster oven can accommodate big items.

With a removable crumb tray, this toaster oven keeps your kitchen counters tidy and free of crumbs. This convection toaster oven has a fan that helps blow warm air over and around the food so that it cooks more thoroughly and much faster. It is designed with auto shutoff, which switches off on its own if you forget or the toaster oven hasn't been used for some time. Made with a ready bell, this toaster oven notifies you when your snack has finished cooking.

This toaster oven comes with a grill rack, a wire shelf, and removal tongs. The timer can be set for up to 60 minutes, making it easier to keep track of how much time remains before your food is done. This toaster oven is great for preparing pizza, sandwiches, hot dogs, and more. It has three knobs and eight pre-set functions for you to choose from.

    Pros
    • Aluminum build makes it a strong yet lightweight choice
    • Designed with an extra large build, making it perfect for big families
    • Auto shutoff switches off on its own
    Cons
    • Convection heating means breads and cakes are less likely to raise
    • Black hue is more trendy than timeless and might go out of fashion
    • Aluminum build is a soft material that is prone to scratching
Runner Up
An image of Maxi-Matic Elite Platinum EBK-300BL Blue Air Fryer Countertop Extra Large Toaster Oven

Choose the Maxi-Matic Elite Platinum Air Fryer Blue Countertop Toaster Oven to warm and cook your food to perfection. This extra large toaster oven is ideal for big families since you can cook more food at one time. Built with an air fryer, this toaster oven heats your food from every angle to mimic the results you get by deep frying. With its blue color, it will brighten any kitchen without being too overwhelming. This retro toaster oven will accent any modern appliances and kitchen decor that you may have. It is constructed for coffee making, is built with a pan frying function, and is designed for baking. Featuring an aluminum build, this toaster oven is a durable yet lightweight choice.

Built with a removable crumb tray, this toaster oven keeps your kitchen counters clean and free of crumbs. The integrated coffeemaker has a Pause 'n serve anti-drip feature, so you can get a cup of coffee before brewing is complete. This toaster oven is perfect for homes, offices, and dorms. It is suitable for preparing biscuits, pancakes, eggs, and more. Its timer can be set for up to 60 minutes, making it easier to keep track of how much time remains before your food is done.

    Pros
    • Aluminum build makes it a lightweight yet strong choice
    • Built-in air fryer mimics the results of deep fried food, but in a much healthier way
    • Designed with an extra large build, making it great for bigger items
    Cons
    • Blue hue might be difficult to match with existing and future appliances
    • Aluminum build is more prone to scratching and denting
Best for Fast Toasting
An image of Avanti PPO84X3S-IS Stainless Steel Convection Toaster Oven

Make exceptionally delicious, toasted food with help from the Avanti Stainless Steel Convection Toaster Oven. Made of aluminum, this toaster oven is a strong yet lightweight choice. With convection heating, it has a fan that circulates the hot air, so your food will toast more thoroughly and at a faster speed. It is stainless steel, giving your counter space a luxurious feel that will always be in style. This toaster oven is constructed for toasting, features a baking function, and has a broiling function, so it will require minimal oil than other ways of cooking. It is made with a stay-on feature for longer cooking time.

    Pros
    • Aluminum construction makes it a lightweight yet durable option
    • Baking function gives you a challenging hobby to begin
    Cons
    • Convection heating means your baked goods are less likely to raise
    • Stainless steel hue shows smudges, marks, and fingerprints
    • Aluminum construction is a soft material that is prone to denting
Additional Picks
An image of Hamilton Beach Proctor Silex 31118R Black Four Slice Toaster Oven

Make incredibly delicious, toasted food by using the Hamilton Beach Proctor Silex Black 4-Slice Toaster Oven. This toaster oven features a ready bell, notifying you when your food has finished cooking. Built with an auto shutoff feature, it turns off on its own if you forget or the toaster oven hasn't been used for some time. It is constructed for toasting, is designed for baking, and has a broiling function, eliminating bad fats from your food. This black toaster oven is a sleek and edgy option that will enhance your kitchen. With an aluminum construction, it is a lightweight yet strong option.

Constructed with a drop-down crumb tray, this toaster oven will keep your kitchen counters tidy and free of crumbs. The timer can be set for up to 15 minutes, so you don't have to keep track of how long your food has been toasting for. This toaster oven is perfect for preparing bread, pizza, biscuits, and more. It has two knobs and one rack.

    Pros
    • Aluminum construction makes it a strong yet lightweight option
    • Auto shutoff turns off on its own
    • Broiling function offers a healthier option of cooking than frying
    Cons
    • Black design shows any spills or dirt
    • Aluminum build is a soft material that isn't very durable
    • Four-slice capacity may produces uneven toasting
An image of Black and Decker P300S Silver Toaster Oven

The Black and Decker Silver Toaster Oven is a must-have item for your kitchen to make exceptionally delicious food. This toaster oven is built for toasting and it is made with a baking function, allowing you to make anything from muffins to pies. Featuring a silver shade, it gives your kitchen a modern feel. This aluminum toaster oven is a strong yet lightweight option.

This toaster oven is designed with a cool touch handle and features auto shutoff so that you are conserving energy for your home while simultaneously keeping it safe. It has a ceramic coated tray, which is scratch and stain resistant. The timer can be set for up to 30 minutes, so you can do other things while waiting for your food to cook without having to worry about it over cooking or burning. This toaster oven is ideal for preparing frozen food and pizza.

    Pros
    • Aluminum construction makes it a lightweight yet strong choice
    • Ceramic coated tray is scratch and stain resistant
    • Auto shutoff switches off on its own
    Cons
    • Silver hue won't add much color to your kitchen
    • Aluminum construction is more prone to denting and scratching
An image of Maxi-Matic Elite Cuisine ERO-2008S Black Countertop Six Slice Toaster Oven

Use the Maxi-Matic Elite Cuisine Black Countertop 6-Slice Toaster Oven to warm and cook your food to perfection. This toaster oven is designed to hold six slices of bread, so you'll have enough space for the entire family's favorite foods. It has a black hue, giving your kitchen a modern look. With an aluminum build, it is a lightweight yet strong choice.

This toaster oven features a rotisserie cooking function, which exposes all sides of the food evenly for delicious taste. It has a power indicator light, which informs you when it is heating up and then makes a noise when the process is complete. The timer can be set for up to 60 minutes, making it easier to keep track of how much time remains before your food is ready. This toaster oven includes a dome lid, a grill rack, and a rotisserie tong. It features three knobs and eight pre-set functions for you to choose from.

    Pros
    • Aluminum construction makes it a durable yet lightweight choice
    • Has a rotisserie cooking function, exposing all sides of the food evenly, for juicy taste
    Cons
    • Black shade is more trendy than timeless and might go out of style
    • Aluminum construction can easily stain and dent
An image of Maxi-Matic Elite Cuisine EBK-200B Black Toaster Oven

Make the most tasty breakfasts with the Maxi-Matic Elite Cuisine Black Toaster Oven. This toaster oven is suitable for preparing eggs and croissants. Featuring a mode selector, it lets you prepare your meals based on your specific preferences. It has a toasting function, is designed for coffee making, and features a griddle cooking function for fluffy pancake making. Built of aluminum, it is a strong yet lightweight choice. This black toaster oven has a sophisticated design that will look perfect on your countertop.

    Pros
    • Aluminum build makes it a durable yet lightweight choice
    • Made for griddle cooking for delicious pancake making
    Cons
    • Black design shows any dirt or spills
    • Aluminum build can easily stain and scratch
If You Need Help Making Your Choice, Here's Some Additional Information About Aluminum Toaster Ovens:
Capacity for an Aluminum Toaster Oven
3-4 Slice Toaster Ovens

If you're looking for a toaster oven that can handle your family's toasting demands, then a 3-4 slice toaster oven may be precisely what you need. We found seven 3-4 slice aluminum toaster ovens that are available today. So check out this aluminum toaster oven to get you started. Generally designed with more browning controls, 3-4 slice toaster ovens give you total control over how crispy you want your food. With increased cooking capacity, they are great when many people need to toast their food at the same time. They are a bit bulky, so if you have small kitchen or limited room on your counter top, you should consider getting a smaller toaster oven. 3-4 slice toaster ovens aren't the best for large households, so if you're looking for a toaster oven for your family to share, you might want to consider one with a larger capacity. They have uneven toasting, resulting in hot and cold spots in the food.

5-8 Slice Toaster Ovens

If you're looking for a toaster oven that can keep up with the toasting demands of your large family, then a 5-8 slice toaster oven may be the ideal solution. To help you decide, we found seven 5-8 slice aluminum toaster ovens that are available today. Click here to check one out. Typically equipped with more browning controls, 5-8 slice toaster ovens give you complete control over your food's crispiness. They can toast multiple items simultaneously, making them great for large families who need to prepare their breakfast quickly before heading out to work or school. Ideal for families, they can help you save time when you and your family are in a rush to get out the door. They are generally expensive, so if you won't be using it often or for many people, you may want to consider a smaller, more affordable option. They feature uneven toasting, so there may be some hot and cold spots in the food after toasting. 5-8 slice toaster ovens are a bit bulky, so if you have small kitchen or limited space on your counter top, you should consider getting a smaller toaster oven.