Best Conventional Toaster Ovens


Our review process

Thinking about getting a new toaster oven but not sure where to start looking? Our team has collected, reviewed, and analyzed information for different kinds of toaster ovens in order to suggest our highest ranked toaster ovens today. Check out some of the benefits and disadvantages of some of the main specs for conventional toaster ovens.

We're here to help you make the right choice when deciding on which conventional toaster oven is best for you. Conventional toaster ovens use radiant heat that comes from the bottom or top of the oven chamber to cook your food. They are more affordable, so you can create tasty and healthy food without spending a ton of money. However, they tend to have hot spots in the back since there is no fan, which could result in over or uneven cooking. Moreover, they lack a rapid flow, which leads to a slower cook time.

Our Top Ranking Toaster Ovens:
Product NameBrandTypeCapacityColorMaterial
Best Overall Score
1
An image of Aicook GH23 Silver Conventional Countertop Six Slice Toaster Oven
Aicook GH23 Silver Conventional Countertop Six Slice Toaster Oven
Aicook
countertop
6
silver
stainless steel
Runner Up
2
An image of Proctor Silex 31124 Conventional Countertop Six Slice Toaster Oven
Proctor Silex 31124 Conventional Countertop Six Slice Toaster Oven
Proctor Silex
countertop
6
Best Affordable Option
3
An image of Black and Decker TO1303SB Black Conventional Countertop Compact Four Slice Toaster Oven
Black and Decker TO1303SB Black Conventional Countertop Compact Four Slice Toaster Oven
Black and Decker
countertop
4
black
stainless steel
4
An image of Wolfgang Puck Essential Silver Conventional Countertop Compact Toaster Oven
Wolfgang Puck Essential Silver Conventional Countertop Compact Toaster Oven
Wolfgang Puck
countertop
silver
5
An image of SHARP ZSSC0586DS Stainless Steel Conventional Countertop Nine Slice Toaster Oven
SHARP ZSSC0586DS Stainless Steel Conventional Countertop Nine Slice Toaster Oven
SHARP
countertop
9
stainless steel
stainless steel
Our Top Ranking Toaster Ovens
Customer Rating
Brand
Aicook
Type
countertop
Capacity
6
Color
silver
Material
stainless steel
Customer Rating
Brand
Proctor Silex
Type
countertop
Capacity
6
Color
Material
Customer Rating
Brand
Black and Decker
Type
countertop
Capacity
4
Color
black
Material
stainless steel
Customer Rating
Brand
Wolfgang Puck
Type
countertop
Capacity
Color
silver
Material
Customer Rating
Brand
SHARP
Type
countertop
Capacity
9
Color
stainless steel
Material
stainless steel
Best Overall Score
An image of Aicook GH23 Silver Conventional Countertop Six Slice Toaster Oven

Cook tasty, toasted food by using the Aicook Silver Countertop Conventional 6-Slice Toaster Oven. This toaster oven can hold up to six slices of bread, making it ideal for large families or for catering environments. It is silver, making it a neutral piece that will never be out of fashion. Built of stainless steel, it is a strong yet lightweight option that will withstand wear and tear.

This toaster oven features adjustable temperature, which prevents your food from over cooking or burning. Featuring auto shutoff, it turns off on its own if you forget or the toaster oven has not been used for some time. It has a baking function, allowing you to make anything from cookies to pies. With a sleek appearance, it will look appealing in any kitchen.

This toaster oven has four different rack positions, which can be cleaned after every use without getting damaged. Its rack is also removable, coming all the way out of the oven, so your food can cool down while still on the rack. The timer can be set for up to 60 minutes, so you don't have to monitor how long your food has been toasting for. This toaster oven includes an oven rack and a baking pan. It has three knobs.

    Pros
    • Stainless steel construction repels rust and stains to keep it in prime condition
    • Auto shutoff will switch off on its own if you forget
    • Four different rack positions allow it to be washed after every use without getting damaged
    Cons
    • Silver design won't add much color to your kitchen
    • Stainless steel construction usually costs more than other materials
Runner Up
An image of Proctor Silex 31124 Conventional Countertop Six Slice Toaster Oven

The Proctor Silex Countertop Conventional 6-Slice Toaster Oven is a must-have appliance for any kitchen to make exceptionally toasted food. With auto shutoff, this toaster oven turns off on its own if you forget or the toaster oven hasn't been used for some time. It has adjustable temperature, which keeps your food from burning or over cooking. This toaster oven is made for toasting, is constructed with a baking function, and has a broiling function, offering a healthier option of cooking than frying.

Featuring 3 contoured knobs, this toaster oven is easy to grasp and turn for anyone. With a front access crumb tray, it keeps your kitchen counters clean and free of crumbs. It features three knobs and three pre-set functions for you to choose from. Its timer can be set for up to 30 minutes, so you can do other things while waiting for your food to cook without having to worry about it over cooking or burning. This toaster oven is great for preparing bread and pizza.

    Pros
    • Auto shutoff is an added benefit if you have a tendency of being forgetful
    • Baking function allows you to make anything from muffins to cakes
    Cons
    • Six-slice capacity takes up more room on your counter top
Best Affordable Option
An image of Black and Decker TO1303SB Black Conventional Countertop Compact Four Slice Toaster Oven

Small enough to fit on your counter top, but large enough to fit your favorite snacks, the Black and Decker Black Countertop Conventional 4-Slice Toaster Oven is fantastic for all of your cooking needs. With a stainless steel build, this toaster oven will complement any decor from modern to traditional. This black toaster oven will add a modern and chic appearance to your countertops. Designed with a compact build, it might not be as powerful as a bigger toaster. It is built with a baking function, is made for toasting, and is constructed for broiling, requiring less oil than other cooking practices.

Featuring a removable crumb tray, this toaster oven makes cleaning up easier than ever. It has a stay-on feature, so you can keep on cooking if your food isn't ready. Offering EvenToast technology, it will toast your bread perfectly. The timer can be set for up to 30 minutes, making it easier to keep track of how much time your food has been cooking for. This toaster oven has three knobs, two racks, and four pre-set functions for you to choose from.

    Pros
    • Stainless steel construction repels stains and rust to keep it in excellent condition
    • Stay-on feature for longer cooking time
    • EvenToast technology toasts your snack completely
    Cons
    • Black shade might make your kitchen look dark
    • Compact build means it might not be as powerful as a bigger toaster
    • Stainless steel construction can scratch easily
Additional Picks
An image of Wolfgang Puck Essential Silver Conventional Countertop Compact Toaster Oven

Toast all your favorite snacks to perfection by using the Wolfgang Puck Essential Silver Countertop Conventional Toaster Oven. This toaster oven is built for broiling, is designed with a baking function, and is constructed for roasting for tender food. Featuring a compact size, it may not be as powerful as a bigger toaster. Made to be energy efficient, it is a great choice for sustainable homes. It is silver, beautifully matching sophisticated and clean decor. This toaster oven has three knobs and five pre-set functions for you to choose from.

    Pros
    • Compact size makes it perfect for small areas
    • Made to be energy efficient, making it a perfect option for environmentally-friendly households
    • Baking function allows you to make anything from muffins to pies
    Cons
    • Silver shade won't add much color to your kitchen
An image of SHARP ZSSC0586DS Stainless Steel Conventional Countertop Nine Slice Toaster Oven

Cook incredibly tasty, toasted meals by using the SHARP Stainless Steel Countertop Conventional 9-Slice Toaster Oven. This toaster oven is designed for warming, is built with a toasting function, and has a broiling function, eliminating bad fats from your food. It is suitable for preparing pizza and chicken. With an easy-to-clean construction, it can be simply wiped down with a damp cloth or towel to get rid of any residue. Designed in stainless steel, it will blend seamlessly with any existing appliances. This stainless steel toaster oven is extremely durable and capable of withstanding many years of use. It has a one knob and five pre-set functions for you to choose from.

    Pros
    • Stainless steel construction will go with your existing appliances
    • Uses a combination of heated steam and radiant heat, allowing the food to retain its authentic food and texture
    • 60-minute timer notifies you when your food is ready
    Cons
    • Stainless steel hue is more expensive than other kinds of materials
    • Stainless steel build requires more cleaning
Some More Information to Help You Decide on Your Conventional Toaster Oven:
Capacity of Conventional Toaster Ovens
3-4 Slice Toaster Ovens

If you're looking for a toaster oven that can keep up with your family's toasting demands, then a 3-4 slice toaster oven may be exactly what you need. We found five 3-4 slice conventional toaster ovens on the market, so keep reading below to learn more. 3-4 slice toaster ovens typically have more browning controls than other toaster ovens, giving you total control over your food's crispiness. With increased cooking capacity, they are perfect when many people need to toast their food at the same time. They have uneven toasting, so you might not get the quality of food you want. 3-4 slice toaster ovens are a bit bulky, so if you have small kitchen or limited space on your counter top, you should consider getting a smaller toaster oven. They aren't the best for large households, so if you're looking for a toaster oven for your whole family to use, you might want to consider something that can fit more food.

5-8 Slice Toaster Ovens

If you're looking for a toaster oven that can handle the toasting demands of your big family, then a 5-8 slice toaster oven may be the perfect solution. For your convenience, we found five 5-8 slice conventional toaster ovens on the market. Click here to check one out. With increased cooking capacity, 5-8 slice toaster ovens will help save you precious time when you and your family are in a rush to get out the door. Generally equipped with a few browning controls, they give you complete control over how crispy you want your toast. They are perfect for families, so more than one person can cook their food simultaneously. 5-8 slice toaster ovens are a bit bulky, so if you have small kitchen or limited space on your counter top, you should consider getting a smaller toaster oven. They are generally expensive, so if you won't be using it often or for many people, you might want to consider a more affordable, smaller option. They feature uneven toasting, so there may be some hot and cold spots in the food after toasting.

Over 9 Slice Toaster Ovens

If you're looking for a toaster oven that can keep up with the toasting demands of a large family, then an over 9 slice toaster oven may be the ideal solution. For your benefit, we found five over 9 slice conventional toaster ovens on the market. With increased cooking capacity, over 9 slice toaster ovens will let you make toast for anyone that wants. Generally equipped with a few browning controls, they give you complete control over how crispy you want your food. They are perfect for families, saving you valuable time when your family is in a rush to get out the door. They are a bit bulky in size, so if you have small kitchen or limited room on your counter top, you should consider getting a smaller toaster oven. They have uneven toasting, so there might be some hot and cold spots in the food after toasting. They are typically expensive, so if you won't be using it often or for many people, you might want to consider a smaller, more affordable toaster oven.