Reviewing Steel Toaster Ovens


Our review process

We've already done all the heavy lifting researching steel toaster ovens. That way, you don't have to pour over confusing reviews about choosing the ideal steel toaster oven for you. By reading this guide, you'll have a better grasp on what types of toaster ovens are available on the market, so you can confidently purchase one that will toast your food to toasted perfection.

Before you choose your new steel toaster oven, there's some stuff you'll want to know. Built of materials that are easy to clean, stainless steel toaster ovens can be easily wiped down with a damp cloth or towel to get rid of any residue. They are corrosion-resistant, staying in excellent condition for long-term use. However, they are prone to scratching, so they will need to be handled delicately in order to keep them from getting damaged. Another downside is that they have heat transmitting materials, making your food colder faster and less appetizing.

Our Top Ranking Toaster Ovens
Best Overall Score
An image of KitchenAid KCO275AQ Aqua Sky Convection Countertop Toaster Oven

The KitchenAid Aqua Sky Countertop Convection Toaster Oven is a must-have item for any kitchen to make exceptionally delicious food. Featuring an aqua sky shade, this toaster oven will add some visual interest and appeal to your countertops. It is built with a baking function, is made for asado roasting, and is constructed for broiling, requiring minimal oil than other cooking practices. This steel toaster oven is extremely strong and able to withstand many years of use.

With convection heating, this toaster oven removes moisture and encourages browning, making it ideal for roasting vegetables. It features adjustable temperature, which prevents your food from over cooking or burning. This toaster oven has two knobs and nine pre-set functions for you to choose from. It includes a cooling rack and a 12" non-stick multipurpose pan. Its timer can be set for up to 120 minutes, making it easier to keep track of how much time remains before your food is ready.

    Pros
    • Steel build is a popular choice due to its excellent strength
    • Baking function allows you to make anything from cookies to pies
    • Designed with even-heat technology, providing a thorough distribution of heat so your food cooks to the best quality
    Cons
    • Convection heating is more fragile and has more breakable parts than other kinds of heating elements
    • Aqua sky design can be too overwhelming in your cooking area
    • Steel construction is hard to keep it fingerprint-free
Runner Up
An image of Hamilton Beach 31123D Silver Convection Countertop Six Slice Toaster Oven

Use the Hamilton Beach Silver Countertop Convection 6-Slice Toaster Oven to cook and warm your food to perfection. With convection heating technology, this toaster oven has a fan inside that circulates the hot air, so your food will cook evenly and at a faster speed. Built with a front access crumb tray, it keeps your counters clean and free of crumbs. It is supplied with an easy-to-clean design, so you can keep it free of any stick foods by simply wiping it down. This toaster oven is designed for toasting, has a broiling function, and features a baking function, which allows you to make anything from scones to cakes. It can be used to prepare cake, pizza, and bread. Made of steel, it will perfectly match with any color. This silver toaster oven will fit in with any kitchen decor from modern to traditional. This toaster oven features two racks and three knobs.

    Pros
    • Steel build will update your kitchen with its neutral color and lustrous finish
    • Baking function allows you to make anything from cookies to cakes
    Cons
    • Convection heating means breads and cakes are less likely to raise
    • Silver hue won't add much color to your kitchen
    • Steel build shows smudges, dirt, and fingerprints
Best for Fast Toasting
An image of Calphalon 1779209 Stainless Steel Convection Extra Large Six Slice Toaster Oven

Cook incredibly tasty, toasted meals with the Calphalon Stainless Steel Convection 6-Slice Toaster Oven. Made of steel, this toaster oven will fit in with any decor from modern to traditional. With a stainless steel hue, it will give your kitchen a modern appearance that will never go out of style. It is extra large, so it can accommodate bigger items, such as frozen pizzas, a whole chicken, or your favorite casserole dishes.

This convection toaster oven has a fan that circulates hot air so that the temperature is constant throughout. This toaster oven has an LCD display, which uses a soft blue or orange backlight that is easy on the eyes. It is made with a non-stick interior, keeping it clean and free from sticky foods. The timer can be set for up to 120 minutes, making it easier to keep track of how much time remains before your food is done. This toaster oven can be used to heat up bagels, pizza, and cookies.

    Pros
    • Steel construction gives your kitchen a sophisticated appearance
    • LCD display uses a soft orange or blue backlight that isn't harsh on your eyes
    • Designed with an extra large build, making it ideal for bigger items
    Cons
    • Convection heating means your baked goods are less likely to raise
    • Stainless steel shade is more expensive than other types of materials
    • Steel build can easily get dented
Additional Picks
An image of Hamilton Beach 31344D Silver Countertop Four Slice Toaster Oven

Cook your food quickly and efficiently using the Hamilton Beach Silver Countertop 4-Slice Toaster Oven. This steel toaster oven is a strong yet lightweight choice that will withstand daily use. This silver toaster oven will add a sleek element and practicality to your cooking area. This toaster oven is designed with a baking function and it features a broiling function and a toasting function. It features a front access crumb tray, which makes cleaning up easier than ever. Easy to clean, it can be easily wiped down with a wet towel or cloth to get rid of any residue. This toaster oven is perfect for heating up pizza and bread.

    Pros
    • Steel build is a popular choice due to its superior strength
    • Baking function allows you to make anything from scones to cakes
    • Four-slice capacity makes it ideal for large families
    Cons
    • Silver shade won't add much color to your kitchen
    • Steel build is hard to keep it smudge-free
    • Four-slice capacity may takes more time to toast your bread
An image of Cuisinart TOA-65 Silver Air Fryer Large Toaster Oven

From warming up food to cooking meals, use the Cuisinart Air Fryer Silver Toaster Oven. This large toaster oven can accommodate big items. With its silver color, this toaster oven will give your kitchen a classic, clean, and sophisticated look. Made of steel, it is extremely strong and able to withstand many years of use. It is designed for reheating, has a baking function, and is constructed for broiling, eliminating bad fats from your food. Constructed with an air fryer, it cooks your food from all angles to mimic the crispy results you get by deep frying. This toaster oven is perfect for preparing bagels and pizza.

    Pros
    • Steel build gives your kitchen a sophisticated appearance
    • Built-in air fryer uses hot air circulation to cook your food from every angle
    • Large size is perfect for big families
    Cons
    • Silver design won't add much color to your kitchen
    • Steel build shows every smudge and fingerprint
An image of Westinghouse WTO1010B Black Four Slice Toaster Oven

The Westinghouse Black 4-Slice Toaster Oven is a much-needed appliance for any kitchen to make exceptionally delicious food. This black toaster oven will add a sleek and modern appearance to your kitchen. This toaster oven is built for toasting, has a baking function, and features a broiling function, which provides a healthier option of cooking than frying. It has a steel build, which won't absorb odors or stains.

With a baking tray, this toaster oven is great for making roasted vegetables and other tasty snacks like french fries. It is made with auto shutoff, turning off on its own if you forget or the toaster oven hasn't been used for some time. It has a stay-on feature for longer cooking time. This toaster oven comes with an oven rack and a baking pan. Its timer can be set for up to 15 minutes, so you don't have to keep track of how long your food has been toasting for.

    Pros
    • Steel build is a durable and rust-resistant choice
    • Auto shutoff turns off on its own
    • Baking function allows you to make anything from scones to pies
    Cons
    • Black shade is harder to match with existing appliances
    • Steel build is hard to keep it fingerprint-free
    • Stay-on feature may become a safety concern if left on for too long
An image of Hamilton Beach Toastation 22720 Black Convection Countertop Extra Wide Four Slice Toaster Oven

The Hamilton Beach Toastation Black Countertop Convection 4-Slice Toaster Oven is a must-have item for any kitchen to make exceptionally delicious food. This convection toaster oven will cook your food evenly, so it won't be too hot in some areas and too cold in other spots. Made with an integrated bread lifter, this toaster oven allows you to check on the status of your food. Featuring dishwasher-safe racks, it can be cleaned after each use without getting damaged. It is made with a toasting function and it is constructed for reheating, so it will allow you to eat your leftovers from yesterday. This toaster oven is ideal for warming up hot dog buns and pizza.

Designed in black, this toaster oven is an ideal choice for industrial and modern style kitchens. Featuring an extra wide size, it can accommodate large items. Constructed of steel, it will resist rust and stains even with everyday use. It has auto shutoff, so you are conserving energy for your home while simultaneously keeping it safe. This toaster oven has one rack, two knobs, and two pre-set functions for you to choose from.

    Pros
    • Steel build is stain and rust resistant
    • Designed with an extra wide build, making it great for big households
    • Auto shutoff switches off on its own
    Cons
    • Convection heating means your baked goods are less likely to raise
    • Black hue is more trendy than timeless and might go out of style
    • Steel build can easily get dented
An image of Proctor Silex 31122 Black Countertop Compact Four Slice Toaster Oven

The Proctor Silex Black Countertop 4-Slice Toaster Oven is a must-have item for your kitchen to make exceptionally delicious meals and snacks. Made with a drop-down crumb tray, this toaster oven keeps your kitchen counters tidy and crumb-free. Supplied with a ready bell, it indicates that your toast is ready to eat. It is ideal for preparing bread, pizza, hamburgers, and more. It is constructed for broiling, is made for toasting, and has a baking function, allowing you to make anything from cookies to cakes.

This compact toaster oven is great for small areas. Featuring a black hue, this toaster oven has a sophisticated design that will look perfect on your countertop. Built of steel, it won't clash with your existing kitchen appliances. It features one rack and three knobs. With auto shutoff, it will turn off on its own if you forget or the toaster oven hasn't been used for some time.

    Pros
    • Steel construction gives your kitchen a modern appearance
    • Compact build will take up minimal counter space, making it great for small kitchens
    • Auto shutoff turns off on its own
    Cons
    • Black shade may make your kitchen look dark
    • Steel construction shows dirt, fingerprints, and smudges
    • Four-slice capacity may produces uneven toasting results
An image of SHARP EO-60K-3 Black Convection Toaster Oven

The SHARP Black Convection Toaster Oven is a much-needed appliance for your kitchen to make exceptionally delicious food. This steel toaster oven will look great with any kitchen decor. With a black hue, this toaster oven has a sleek design that will look perfect on any countertop. It features convection heating, cooking your food more quickly and consistently. Its timer can be set for up to 60 minutes, making it easier to keep track of how much time remains before your food is ready.

    Pros
    • Steel construction is made to withstand years of wear and tear
    • Convection heating will remove moisture and encourage browning
    • 60-minute timer will notify you once your food is ready to eat
    Cons
    • Convection heating means cakes and breads are not as likely to raise
    • Black design might make your kitchen look darker than it is
    • Steel construction requires more cleaning
Learn More About Steel Toaster Ovens:
Steel Toaster Ovens Comes in Different Sizes
Small Toaster Ovens

If you've been searching for a small steel toaster oven, then you should keep reading below to learn more about them. If you have limited room in your kitchen and need to save precious counter space, small toaster ovens are a perfect option for you. These small toaster ovens use less energy, providing an eco-conscious option for your household. However, they feature a low capacity, which prevents you from being able to cook more food at the same time. On top of that, they generally have shorter cords, so you'll have to place them near an electrical plug to toast your food.

Large Toaster Ovens

If you're looking for a large steel toaster oven, then you should check out some of the things we have to say below. Made to fit heftier food items, large toaster ovens allow you to bake things like turkey. They have greater functionality than typical toaster ovens for more diverse and exotic cooking options. Built with multiple tiers, they allow you to bake multiple items at once. These large toaster ovens are bigger so they take up more space on your counter top, leaving little space for other kitchen appliances.